Jimmy Matthew and the Great Piedmont Bake-Off Fiasco

Townsfolk commentary included, because Piedmont never lets foolishness pass without documentation.

A Piedmont Lantern Story

If there was one event Piedmont took seriously, it was the Annual Spring Bake-Off at the Methodist Fellowship Hall. Folks treated it like a culinary showdown at high noon. Flour flew. Frostin’ hardened. Judges readied their palates like surgeons preparin’ for heart surgery.

And that was exactly why Jimmy Matthew and Jim Leroy should never have been allowed within fifty feet of it.

But fate intervened in the form of Miss Loretta McVee, who cornered them outside Lively’s Grocery and said these immortal words:

“Boys, I reckon you got strong backs and no common sense. Come help us unload supplies for the bake-off.”

They heard “help,” but what stuck in their heads was “bake-off.”
Their eyes gleamed.

Lord help Piedmont.

The Plan Forms

The boys met behind the fellowship hall, where the dumpsters lived out their quiet and dignified retirement.

“Jimmy,” Jim Leroy said, “I reckon we oughta enter the contest.”

“We cain’t cook,” Jimmy replied.

“Well, neither can half the men in town, and they still enter. Why not us?”

Jimmy scratched his chin.

“We need somethin’ show-stoppin’. Somethin’ folks will talk about for years.”

“Like a cake shaped like Dugger Mountain?”

Jimmy grinned.

“More like a cake that erupts. A volcano cake. With real smoke.”

Jim Leroy’s eyebrows arched so high they nearly left his head.

“You think we can make a smokin’ cake?”

“No,” Jimmy said, “but we can make a cake that has smoke near it.”

The Attempt

Step one was findin’ a cake.

Neither boy wanted to bake, so they “borrowed” a pound cake Miss Ora Nell had just set on the windowsill to cool.

Technically, they were returnin’ it as a masterpiece, so they felt morally upright.

Step two was addin’ the “volcano” element.

“Dry ice,” Jimmy declared. “That is what real magicians use.”

Problem was, they didn’t have dry ice.
What they did have was:

  • A leftover Fourth of July smoke bomb
  • A funnel
  • A cake with a hollowed-out center
  • Bad judgment

They loaded it, packed it, and prayed.

The Big Reveal

At precisely 3:15 p.m., during the judging portion of the bake-off, the boys carried their creation to the long table beside the banana puddings and chess pies.

The room went still.

Mrs. Hazel Turnipseed, three-time Bake-Off Champion, folded her arms.

Miss Ora Nell sniffed suspiciously.

“Smells like sulfur in here,” she said. “Somebody light a match?”

Jimmy cleared his throat.

“Ladies and gentlemen,” he announced, “we present to you the world’s first active eruption cake. Behold… Mount Piedmont.”

He tapped the funnel.

Nothing happened.

He tapped it again.

Still nothing.

Jim Leroy shrugged and reached under the table to jiggle the smoke bomb.

That was the mistake.

The cake erupted with a hiss so loud it startled the entire room. Thick gray smoke belched upward, fillin’ the fellowship hall like a battlefield reenactment.

People screamed.

Pies were abandoned.

Children hid under tables.

Miss Ora Nell collapsed against a stack of hymnals wailin’, “The Good Lord done called me home!”

Mrs. Hazel Turnipseed shouted, “Grab the fire extinguisher! And my pudding!”

The Preacher busted in yellin’, “Who summoned the biblical plague? Who?”

And through it all, Jimmy Matthew stood there, proud as a whitewashed pig.

The Townsfolk Commentary

When the smoke cleared (twenty minutes and two box fans later), Piedmont had opinions.

Mrs. Hazel Turnipseed:
“If they wanted drama, they should have joined the choir.”

Miss Ora Nell:
“That was my pound cake. My pound cake. Those boys are lucky I believe in grace.”

Pastor Willoughby:
“Never again. Not even with chaperones. Especially not with chaperones.”

Sheriff Garner:
“I cain’t arrest ‘em for cookin’, but I can strongly suggest they never do it again.”

Raymond Rue:
“I ain’t sayin’ it was impressive, but I will say my eyebrows are still smokin’.”

Claire Woolf:
“I told them not to. I told them three times. That means I get to say ‘I told you so’ until next Easter.”

The Aftermath

The boys received a lifetime ban from the Bake-Off, which they took as a badge of honor.
Miss Ora Nell forgave them after they replaced her pound cake.
Mrs. Hazel won again because the judges felt sentimental.

And Jimmy Matthew declared the event a success.

“We made history,” he said.

“Yep,” Jim Leroy agreed. “Just wish history didn’t smell like burnin’ rubber.”

The fellowship hall has not allowed open flames, fireworks, or boys named Jimmy Matthew or Jim Leroy inside since.

And Piedmont, bless its heart, still talks about the year the cake erupted.

Unknown's avatar

About Ol' Big Jim

Jim L. Wright is a storyteller with a lifetime of experiences as colorful as the characters he creates. Born and raised in Piedmont, Alabama, Jim’s connection to the land, history, and people of the region runs deep. His debut novel New Yesterdays is set in his hometown, where he grew up listening to stories of the past—stories that sparked his imagination and curiosity for history. Today, Jim lives in Leeds, Alabama, with his husband Zeek, a tour operator who shares his passion for adventure and discovery. Known affectionately as “Ol’ Big Jim,” he has had a diverse career that includes time as a storekeeper, an embalmer, a hospital orderly, and a medical coder. There are even whispers—unconfirmed, of course—that he once played piano in a house of ill repute. No matter the job, one thing has remained constant: Jim is a teller of tales. His stories—sometimes humorous, sometimes thought-provoking—are often inspired by his unique life experiences. Many of these tales can be found on his popular blog, Ol’ Big Jim, where he continues to share his musings with a loyal readership. Jim’s adventures have taken him far beyond Alabama. For seven years, he lived in Amman, Jordan, the world’s oldest continuously inhabited city. His time there, spent in smoky coffee shops, enjoying a hookah and a cup of tea while scribbling in his ever-present notebook, deeply influenced his worldview and his writing. When Jim isn’t writing, he’s thinking about writing. His stories, whether tall tales from his past or imaginative reimagining is of historical events should read from his past or imaginative reimaginings of historical events, reflect a life lived fully and authentically. With New Yesterdays, Jim brings readers a rich tapestry of history, fantasy, and human connection. Visit his blog at www.olbigjim.com to read more of his stories, or follow him on social media to keep up with his latest musings and projects, one of which is a series that follows Bonita McCauley, an amateur detective who gets into some very sticky situations. His book, New Yesterdays, can be found at Amazon US, Amazon UK, Smashwords, and Barnes and Noble.
This entry was posted in Piedmont Lantern Stories and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

What did you think of this tall tale? Let me know in the comments section; I'd love to hear from you!